Instant Quote

Pros & Cons Of Luxury Asphalt Shingles & Top 5 Picks In 2024

Posted on November 26, 2022

Estimated Reading Time : 5 Min.

Share Now :
Pros & Cons Of Luxury Asphalt Shingles & Top 5 Picks In 2024

Luxury asphalt shingles blend style and performance, keeping your home safe and attractive for decades! Top shingle manufacturers like GAF and Owens Corning have some of the best options in store. If you want to compare luxury shingles or find out which one is best for your home, we’ve got you covered.

At RST Roofing & Renovations, we aim to help you make the right roofing decisions for your home. This article explains:

  • What luxury asphalt shingles are;
  • Their pros and cons; and
  • The top five choices of 2024 that fit most U.S. homes.

What Are Luxury Asphalt Shingles?

Luxury asphalt shingles are the premium shingle lines offered by many brands. They have the appearance of authentic slate tiles and are thicker than architectural or laminated shingles. Premium shingles are an excellent choice to enhance your home’s curb appeal, safety, and resale value.

luxury asphalt shingles


These premium shingles have multiple layers and enhanced patterns, making them more stylish, durable, and energy-efficient. Luxury shingles can withstand heat, hail, heavy rains, and snow storms better than any other shingle type. With proper upkeep, luxury shingles can last for 50 years! They can also protect your home better against fires and wind uplift. The most beneficial feature of asphalt shingles is that they cost less than other premium roofing materials, such as wood shakes, metals, natural slate, and clay tiles.


Premium asphalt shingles cost more than standard shingle types like organic asphalt, fiberglass, 3-tab, and architectural shingles. To take advantage of extended warranties (30 to 50 years), you must install a few necessary brand accessories and hire a brand-certified roofing contractor.

Nevertheless, premium shingles have proved to be a cost-effective option over the years since they are more durable, energy-efficient, and don’t require frequent repairs. Here are the five best luxury shingles in 2024:

Five Best Luxury Asphalt Shingles Of 2024

GAF, Owens Corning, CertainTeed, Malarkey, and Atlas have the industry’s highest impact-resistant and durable shingles. We’ve created a list of top-performing luxury shingles based on customer reviews and shingle features.

#1 CertainTeed Grand Manor®

CertainTeed is a premium brand with the highest-performing shingles and roofing products. This sets the price of their products a little higher, but their Grand Manor shingles are the most sturdy luxury shingles on the market.

  • Top-of-the-line luxury roofing shingles with five-layered composition
  • 10-year standard warranty and 50-year transferable limited lifetime warranty
  • Eight diverse shades with the most authentic slate look on the market
  • Maximum Definition color technology for an elevated 3D look.
  • StreakFighter® technology with a 15-year algae resistance warranty
  • CertaSeal™ wind uplift protection adhesive. The industry’s best wind uplift resistance for up to 130 mph wind gusts.
  • 10-year and 15-year wind warranties
  • NailTrak®, three factory-made tracking lines for accurate and even nailing

CertainTeed Grand Manor® shingles cost around $220-$245 per square, and the labor charges can be about $130-$240 per square, depending on the current weather conditions.

#2 Owens Corning Berkshire®

Owens Corning develops the most reasonably priced luxury shingles on the market. Many homeowners’ associations highly recommend their Berkshire® range. Owens Corning Berkshire® shingles come with the industry’s finest warranty, algae protection, installation technology, and curb appeal.

  • 10-year standard warranty and limited lifetime warranty
  • 10-year to 25-year workmanship coverage
  • StreakGuard™ algae protection technology
  • 15-year algae protection warranty
  • 130 mph wind resistance (F1 tornado speed ranges from 70 to 113 mph)
  • SureNail® technology with a unique fabric in the nailing area for accurate installation
  • TruDefinition® color platform for rich, dramatic colors and high-definition look.

The colonial and concord-style Berkshire® shingles cost about $215 per square. The shingles form an elegant look for your home that can enhance its value by 10%.

#3 Malarkey Windsor®

While most designer and premium shingles are made of recycled materials, Malarkey adds additional eco-friendliness to their shingles. They plant two trees for each roof installed with Malarkey shingles and use plastic bags and tires from landfills to manufacture most materials.

Malarkey Windsor® shingles was the first luxury shingle made from rubber-modified asphalt. TIME Magazine also featured Malarkey Windsor® shingles in their 50 Best Inventions of 2018.

  • 15-year non-prorated warranty and limited lifetime warranty
  • NEX® rubberized asphalt shingle technology for highest hail resistance
  • Malarky Vista offers a standard shingle warranty of up to 12 years and extended lifetime warranties.
  • 65% higher granule adhesion than the ASTM D3462 industry standard
  • Enhanced wind warranty against 140 mph wind speeds
  • 50% stronger shingle adhesive bonds than standard shingles
  • The Zone® nailing area is twice as large as standard-size shingles.
  • 40% greater tear resistance than the ASTM D3462 industry standard
  • 3M™ copper granules and ScotchGuard™ protector for excellent algae resistance
  • Limited lifetime algae warranty
  • 3M™ smog-reducing granules purify the air by converting harmful gasses into salt ions.

Malarkey believes their shingles can surpass all the other warranty periods shingle manufacturers offer. Malarkey Windsor® shingles cost around $158 to $164 per square.

#4 Atlas StormMaster Slate®

Atlas has been innovating construction products since 1982. Atlas StormMaster Slate® shingles are currently one of the most preferred shingles by U.S. homeowners. They are also highly sturdy and come with the quickest installation technology.

They come with Core4™ technology, which is one of the most advanced and valuable developments in the asphalt shingle industry. The Core4 technology includes:

PolyCore: Advanced polymer-infused shingles

FlexCore: Flexible composition to resist breaking and cracking in the winter

WeatherCore: Resistant to hail, impacts, and hurricane-force winds

ThermalCore: Advanced granule adhesive technology to resist deterioration due to moisture, sun exposure, and high heat.

  • Lifetime limited warranty, starting from 10 years
  • Wind resistance of up to 150 mph
  • 110 mph limited wind warranty
  • Scotchgard™ Protector technology to prevent black algae and black streaks.
  • HP42, the biggest shingle size on the market
  • SweetSpot, a large nailing area, almost double the size of most roofing shingles
  • FASTAC®, a double adhesive technology for shorter installation time

Atlas StormMaster Slate® shingles cost around $105 to $124 per square.

 #5 GAF Camelot® II

GAF Camelot® II shingles have some exciting features. These French slate-style shingles have four layers, which include, a fiberglass mat, an asphalt layer, limestone granules, and an adhesive layer.

  • 10-year and 50-year warranties
  • Time-release algae-fighting technology
  • 25-year StainGuard Plus™ algae protection warranty
  • StrikeZone, the widest shingle nailing area
  • Dura Grip technology for enhanced shingle handling
  • Excellent shingle sealing ability with LayerLock technology
  • Impressive wind warranty that covers infinite wind speeds for 10 years

GAF Camelot® II is a luxury, costing around $60.99 per bundle, and the installation cost may be the same as the other luxury shingles.

While all these shingles have impressive features, your final decision should depend on your budget and aesthetic requirements. CertainTeed Grand Manor® has more color options, and Atlas StormMaster Slate® is more affordable.

However, your roofing experience also depends on other aspects you should consider as well, such as:

If you need help choosing the best asphalt shingles, we can help you make the right choice for your home.

Discuss Luxury Shingles & More Options With The Experts

RST Roofing & Renovations has been serving Atlanta, Georgia, and the surrounding area for years. If you live in Georgia, we know how the coastal weather affects roofing materials and your investment. Our team is a part of the community, and we give our best to improving homes in a fair and friendly way. RST Roofing & Renovations is proud to be CertainTeed Shingle Master Contractor and Owens Corning’s preferred contractor.

If you want to discuss more about luxury asphalt shingles or other roofing materials with our experts, call us at (404)-548-8901. We will be happy to offer you a free consultation and estimate.

Skip to content